Content Hub

Email isn’t dead. It’s evolving: What the 2026 benchmarks mean for membership organisations

  • Blog
  • 07 May
  • 8 mins
  • Kirstie Buchanan

Please note our content disclaimer in relation to blog posts. 

Why connected email strategies matter more in 2026

Email remains one of the most effective channels for membership organisations in 2026 – but the way it delivers value has fundamentally changed. 

The real shift isn’t that email is changing, it’s that the way organisations use it hasn’t kept up.

For membership organisations, email marketing continues to be a critical part of digital strategy, particularly when integrated with CRM, web, and member data to support engagement, retention, and long-term value.

Dotdigital’s Global Benchmark Report 2026 shows that email performance remains strong. Global email open rates rose to 55.4%, up 6.5% year on year, while delivery rates held at 99.21% despite increased send volumes. 

Dotdigital’s findings also suggest that email is increasingly being used as a discovery and context-setting channel, helping organisations build relevance and support decision-making across the customer journey.

Email continues to be one of the most resilient and effective owned channels, but its role is evolving. We’re seeing it move beyond campaign delivery to become a key part of connected, cross-channel journeys, helping organisations build context, relevance, and long-term engagement with their audiences.

Natasha Lillibury Content Marketing Manager & Author of Global Benchmark Report, Dotdigital

The definition shift: what an effective email strategy looks like in 2026

In 2026, an effective email strategy for membership organisations is one that is fully integrated with CRM, behavioural data, and member journeys – not one that focuses on campaign volume.

This is the shift from email as a standalone channel to part of a connected digital ecosystem.


From email campaigns to connected member journeys

The Digital Excellence Report 2026 from MemberWise shows a sector that is progressing, but still has clear maturity gaps.

  • 61% of organisations measure member engagement 
  • 43% personalise online experiences 
  • 19% use behavioural data such as views and clicks 
  • 14% align digital investment with a clear strategy 

This highlights a key challenge for membership organisations. Email is performing, but it is often not connected to the systems and data that drive meaningful member engagement.

At Cantarus, we work with membership organisations to connect email marketing with CRM, web platforms, and data layers – enabling more effective, joined-up engagement across the full member lifecycle.


Smarter orchestration, not more volume

The most effective email strategies in 2026 are those integrated with CRM, behavioural data, and member journeys, rather than those focused purely on campaign output.

The opportunity is not sending more email – it's sending more relevant, better-timed communication.

Dotdigital highlights several areas shaping modern email strategy:

  • Send-time optimisation based on engagement behaviour 
  • AI-assisted content creation and subject line support 
  • Improved preference and consent management 
  • Stronger data hygiene, with global bounce rates at 0.79% 

These innovations allow organisations to scale personalisation without increasing operational complexity – but only when supported by the right data and governance.

The MemberWise report reinforces this. While 26% of organisations are now using AI, only 6% have a defined AI strategy in place.

For many membership organisations, the challenge is no longer whether email works – the data shows that it does. The real challenge is whether it’s connected well enough to CRM, member data, and digital journeys to create relevance at the moments that matter. That’s where we see organisations start to unlock significantly more value.

Steven Madden Commercial Director CRM, Cantarus

Why clicks need a more mature interpretation

Email performance is also evolving in how it should be measured.

Dotdigital reports:

  • Click-through rate: 3.7% 
  • Unique click-through rate: 1.4% 
  • Click-to-open rate declining from 4.1% to 3.7% 

This reflects a shift in how audiences engage with email.

Email is increasingly used to:

  • Build awareness 
  • Provide context 
  • Support decision-making 
  • Reinforce value over time 

For membership organisations, where engagement is ongoing rather than transactional, this provides a more complete view of how email contributes to retention and growth.


Integration across the ecosystem

The MemberWise findings highlight that integration remains a key barrier:

  • 78% have CMS integration 
  • 66% have CRM/AMS integration 
  • 54% have email marketing integration
  • But wider ecosystem integration still lags 

This is where many email strategies stall. Without integration across CRM, web, community platforms, and data layers:

  • Personalisation remains surface-level 
  • Journeys remain fragmented 
  • Value remains limited 

This isn't a channel problem. It is an ecosystem design challenge.

This is where organisations benefit from working with partners who understand both the technology and the membership model – connecting platforms like Dotdigital with CRM, web, and community ecosystems to support long-term engagement.

This is also where organisations typically see the greatest shift – connecting email platforms like Dotdigital into CRM (including Microsoft Dynamics), web and data environments to support continuous improvement through insight, testing, and optimisation over time.

What this means for membership organisations

Email is no longer a standalone campaign tool. It has become a connected engagement layer that supports member journeys across CRM, web, and digital platforms.

Its value comes not just from strong deliverability and engagement, but from how effectively it supports long-term member relationships when integrated across the wider digital ecosystem.


What this means for your email strategy

The organisations seeing the greatest return from email marketing in 2026 are not those sending more campaigns.

They are the ones asking better questions:

  • How well is our email strategy connected to CRM and member data? 
  • Are we using behavioural signals to drive relevance? 
  • Are we designing journeys – or just campaigns? 
  • Are we measuring email beyond clicks? 
  • Do our systems support orchestration across the member lifecycle? 


Key takeaways for membership organisations

  • Email marketing remains highly effective, with 55.4% open rates and 99.21% delivery rates (Dotdigital Global Benchmark Report 2026) 
  • The biggest opportunity is not volume, but connected, data-driven member journeys 
  • Many organisations still lack behavioural personalisation and integration (MemberWise Digital Excellence Report 2026) 
  • Email delivers the most value when integrated with CRM, web, and member data 
  • AI and automation are growing, but require clear governance and strategy to deliver value 


Final thoughts

Email isn’t going anywhere, but the organisations that will see the greatest return in 2026 are those using it as part of a connected, insight-driven member experience.

We’re working with membership organisations to connect email, CRM, and digital platforms into joined-up member journeys. If you’re exploring how to do this more effectively, we’d be happy to share what’s working – and where organisations are seeing the biggest gains.

​Build more connected member journeys

Learn how integrated digital ecosystems help membership organisations deliver more personalised and effective member experiences.

Get In Touch